Friday, June 08, 2007

Another... Part 2

It seems our decision to only have 1 child has bothered some people. Some have been brave and left their concerns in the comment section. Others have only mentioned it to me in person or through email.

Thank you. I appreciate all of it. I really do. And I guess I should have made it more clear that our decision is not "set in stone." As with all things... we are free to change our minds at some point in the future. But that is the decision that is best, and "right" for us at this time.

And really... let's look at the most common arguments I'm given as to WHY we should reconsider our decision. I hear 2 the most often...

"I've never met an 'only' who didn't wish they had a sibling."
Maybe. Probably. But when you asked them... did you ask an only child who wanted a playmate, or an adult? And if you asked an adult... what were their reasons? Because it would have been nice to have a friend growing up? Because they always thought it would be neat to have a brother or sister? Or are they lonely into adulthood? Is their wish to have a sibling a carryover from the past... or is it current and strong in the present and looking to the future? Is there something they feel is missing in their adult lives that could only be filled by a sibling? For that matter.... how do they know a sibling would fill it... having never had one to know what the experience is like? Not to mention....... I know plenty of adults who have very "strained" relationships with their siblings... some to the point of wishing they were an 'only'....... so it can go both ways.

and the other I hear the most...

"What about when you're gone? Do you want him to be alone?"
Of course I don't. But, I would like to think that as parents... we'll raise him so he wouldn't have to be. To be a warm, friendly adult with friends and family of his own. Maybe he'll get married. Maybe he won't. That choice will be up to him. But, not having a sibling does not banish him to a lifetime of loneliness. He already has grandparents and aunts and uncles and cousins. And a church family. And friends. Why does the loss of his parents mean he would suddenly be alone? I don't think that it does.


Believe me. I've thought about these things hundreds of times. And all the "what ifs" you can muster. Want to know the truth? Part of me is afraid to have another. There. I said it. I'm afraid. I'm afraid of having a girl. (don't want one... at all!) I'm afraid of going through another miscarriage. I'm afraid of what it would do to us financially. I'm afraid of how a second child would take time from the first.

Fear aside. There is no one, right answer. You just have to weigh the good, the bad and the ugly and come up with the choice that fits best. Right now... for us... that is to have one child.

6 comments:

Nina said...

Kitkat,

I am an only child. An only child that grew up with lot's of friends. An only child that really never missed siblings. I never asked my parents for them. I am an only child that most probably is choosing to have an only child myself. I have several very close friends, that I love much more than many of my friends love their siblings.

I don't anybody for what they think, I just want you to know that I have always been a content only child.

I congratulate you on your decision to only one, but if there will be another one in the future, I will be equally happy for you. One never knows what happens....

The day my parents die (I hope that's still a long time until then), my husband and best friends will be next to my side, and of course my child. I won't be alone, I know that.

Rumour Miller said...

It's your decision, hon. You have to do what is right for you and your family... families come in all forms, shapes and sizes.

Melissa said...

Kat,
You know I heard all the same things for years! It was our decision to make and my decision was based on what I want, not everyone else. Look at after saying over and over I only want 1, I changed my mind. You may find one is just the right number for you. :-) If not, you will come to that, but for now I wouldn't even worry about it. Just enjoy the fact you have that adorable little guy to spend your time with. Whatever is meant to happen will.

Anonymous said...

Kat; I am an only child. But you know what...I turned out ok. You went through many things that alot of people do not know or understand...SO if you and DH decide only 1 then its only 1. There is NOTHING wrong with that. Do not let ANYONE make you feel guilty or that your child is going to suffer. He will not.
Dawnie

kristie said...

it is ur choice... never let any one tell you what it right or wrong for your family...right after i read your blog.. i read this one.. and wanted to share
http://suzeo99.blogspot.com/2007/06/june-16.html

Anonymous said...

I'm an only child. I never really thought about another sibling growing up and I wasn't incredibly lonely. I'm lonely now, but that's MY fault and has nothing to do w/ the fact that I'm an only child. Contrary to popular belief, only children do turn out normal! =)